Tuesday 6 December 2016

A Marking Revolution?


Marking: it’s the issue that perhaps adds most to the workload of teachers and for many of us seems like painting the Forth Bridge, but harder. These days it gets paired up to make a double act: marking and feedback, but in fact these are two quite separate things.
We know from the work of Prof. John Hattie and the Sutton Trust that feedback has one of the highest effect sizes in all evidences teaching strategies. This alone gives us the mandate to seek to improve the quality of our feedback to students, and why so many of us spend so long doing it. But is marking the same as feedback? It would seem not.

As the recent report by the Education Endowment Foundation, ‘A Marked Improvement’ (Elliott et al., April 2016) states: “Careless mistakes should be marked differently to errors resulting from misunderstanding.” This makes the distinction that marking highlights errors: spelling mistakes, grammatical errors, carelessness through lack of effort or not proof-reading. Feedback, then, should aim to clear up misunderstandings, and if we want students to understand where they have gone wrong, we traditionally write our feedback on their work, and this takes the most time and effort.

We often find ourselves writing the same thing over and over as we plough through student books or writing lengthy comments to re-iterate what we said in class. And it’s this that contributes to make marking such a chore.

The EEF’s report outlines some key findings that we can learn from when we assess the impact of our marking and our feedback to students. Here are some of the main points and what they might mean for us:

“The quality of existing evidence focused specifically on written marking is low.”

This is surprising, as it makes up such a huge part of our workload. However, what little has been discovered helps us form a more flexible approach to the way we mark. What has been gleaned is detailed below:

“Careless mistakes should be marked differently to errors resulting from misunderstanding. The latter may be best addressed by providing hints or questions which lead pupils to underlying principles; the former by simply marking the mistake as incorrect, without giving the right answer.”

‘Careless mistakes’ are likely to take the form of SPaG errors, primarily. Two strategies that can help with this: 

1) Ensuring that work is proof-read before it is handed in. Students can either do this themselves, or swap with a peer to check against key words stipulated by the teacher or directed inclusions about workings-out and presentation. Don’t take work in unless this has been done. This would take 5 minutes tops.

2) Any errors you spot can be pointed out by underlining the error and marking it with a © (Check and Correct). Subjects such as MFL may have a list of marking codes here to support more complex grammatical errors, although keeping codes to a minimum has more impact. Have dictionaries on desks and students can correct these errors themselves.

“Pupils are unlikely to benefit from marking unless some time is set aside to enable pupils to consider and respond to marking”

DIRT (Directed Improvement and Response Time) is essential: without it you can feel like a yappy dog barking at the postman from the other side of the door, as your barking, or rather, feedback will have minimal impact. Building DIRT into lessons is not time-wasted, it’s time invested. But do heed the following warning too:


“Some forms of marking, including acknowledgement marking, are unlikely to enhance pupil progress. A mantra might be that schools should mark less in terms of the number of pieces of work marked, but mark better.”

DIRT is to allow the students make the work better and produce improved responses to the standard you have asked for. A comment from a teacher saying ‘You need to write more for an 8 mark question’ can elicit the response ‘Ok thanks Miss, I will next time’, which is all very polite, but has little impact. The feedback (oral or written) ‘Please re-do this again, this time with more detail’ should be an instruction and that is what the DIRT is for.

“There is an urgent need for more studies so that teachers have better information about the most effective marking approaches.”

We’re on it! In a bid to make feedback more meaningful but less onerous for the teacher, several subject areas at CWLC have been trialing different approaches to marking and feedback. One particular resource is being tried out in maths, MFL and English:

The whole-class feedback grid


A generic copy of a whole-class marking & feedback grid (referred to now as M&F grids) is here.
Methodology: The idea of these sheets is that, instead of marking every book closely and writing individual comments on every book, teachers read every book and only make the minimum number of interventions: e.g. question marks, any SPaG marking codes agreed by the dept., comments for that particular student based on your knowledge of their effort, etc.

As a teacher reads the books, they jot down notes using the M&F grid to highlight excellent work/effort, common problems, misconceptions, missing work, absences, common keyword issues, etc. The next lesson begins with this feedback being shared with the whole group, which can be done in a number of ways. The students then act on this feedback before moving on.

Martin Goffe (HoD MFL) presented to the T&L group recently how he and others in MFL had been using the M&F grids. MFL use a list of annotation codes to indicate a range of issues that commonly occur in MFL written work. The teacher annotates work with these codes in green.

They then use the grid to make further notes. In the example Martin gave, he had typed his feedback comments onto Powerpoint slides so the whole class would see (he said this only took 5 minutes as he was simply copying from his notes). The first slides started with www comments with students gaining individual praise for work done well, with examples of why this was excellent (shown below). This worked as a model for improvement.


The next slides were highlighting common errors (this time with no student names/initials). This acts as a prompt so students can look to see if they made the same errors. Going through the slides took 10 minutes then the DIRT that followed was probably 15 minutes more.



Martin’s pros: ‘Marking took less time; I was able to give more specific praise and therefore felt it impacted positively on students’ self-esteem and confidence; it promoted more independence in the students.’  Cons: ‘None as far as marking/feedback method goes, but I think the marking codes MFL are using could be reduced as students progress, reducing the level of scaffolding and promoting even more independence in improving their own work.’

Tess Thomas (AHT & maths) presented how the whole maths department has been using these M&F grid (below)



With maths being marked far more frequently (in terms of right or wrong answers) than some other subjects, Tess said she doesn’t write the feedback onto slides. Classwork is always marked there and then for instant feedback with the students doing self and peer marking. Tess only marks homework closely. She then gives the feedback orally and directs it towards individuals. Best work is highlighted first, with two ‘BBs’ (Best Books) chosen each week. The BB students then act as Learning Ambassadors to support other students during DIRT. Students needing support are told why and then paired with Learning Ambassadors to improve the work. Each maths teacher also keeps their grids and files them as a record of student progress which Iglika Gillam (maths) says is very helpful when writing reports. Although it has been adopted across the maths department, teachers are using their grids in slightly different ways. For Tess, pros: ‘I feel the quality of my feedback has improved; I’m able to reflect more on what I plan for subsequent lessons more accurately; the time taken to mark is reduced.’ Cons: ‘None as yet!’

If departments want to try this method out, we would advise you adapt the generic form, as each department will have different needs and priorities in their marking. 

Endorsed by our Head of English Karen Cunningham, a few of us have also been giving the grids a try. Here's one I tried myself for some marking for a year 7 descriptive writing task. 




I later did what Martin had done and copied my notes onto slides to start the lesson off. I like to think I'm good at giving out praise but it turns out, when I compare my previous habits with using this grid, not so much. It was lovely being able to start the lesson with some specific praise for individuals and seeing how this affected the students' pride in themselves and their work. I was able to target some quite complex grammatical improvements with the whole class too, so that everyone could see and hear my comments and they weren't just aimed at particular high fliers and lost in their books. When they were doing their DIRT following this, I noticed it was much more purposeful than usual; students were comparing errors and praise, and working with one another to model best work. I was surprised at how successful the whole process had been.

It also showed me that the original grid needed to be tweaked to allow more space for praise, which I did ready for the next piece they do for me:

Another thing I really like about these grids and the feedback we're getting from teachers in lots of departments is just how flexible it is: each department is finding their own way with them, which surely indicates an engagement with the process looking for impact, rather than a whole-school one-size-fits-all approach.


The elephant in the room?

When sharing these and other alternative feedback methods, the most commonly-heard response from teachers tends to be “But what will Ofsted and SLT say? Won’t they want to see lots of teacher comments and student/teacher dialogue?”

The response to this is a resounding “NO!”, from Ofsted, and from our SLT after we discussed this recently. (My HT insisted I write this in bold. And red. In caps. I should add too that he's an Ofsted Inspector.)

Ofsted Chief Sean Harford’s recent document “Marking and other myths” (Nov 2016) states: ‘I have asked our inspectors when reporting to not give any impression that marking needs to be undertaken in any particular format and to any particular degree of sophistication or detail; this lines up with our myth busting document and the school inspection handbook deals with this.’

Read the whole (short) article here for details but he is very clear on this.

And our own Headteacher Neil Morris says: 

In our reviews, student work is always going to be scrutinised and will help provide evidence for student progress over time. But that progress is achieved in a variety of ways. As long as we demand high standards of literacy and presentation, and students have improved work when it is not good enough or when it shows misunderstandings, then that is evidence enough that feedback has informed this, whatever form the feedback takes. We don’t need stickers or stamps, or written conversations because that’s clearly done for me, or SLT, not the students! We do read students’ work, so we know when it reflects good teaching and high expectations.’

Our action research on this continues and will help inform policy when we review our whole-school approach to both marking and feedback. Watch this space!

59 comments:

  1. Hi Rachel,

    I’m contacting you from Twenty Twenty, a television production company that makes programmes such as First Dates and Gareth Malone’s The Naked Choir.

    We’re currently producing a brand new studio based programme presented by Davina McCall that will help tackle and dispel the myths around modern day dilemmas and themes we all face. On each programme we will be covering topics such as friendships, parenting, stress, careers, technology and mental health.

    We are currently casting for people to appear on the show and the episode with any experts selected will be tailored towards them.

    In our research we’ve found that teaching is one of the most stressful professions. Having looked at your blog, we know that you have a great following of really hardworking teachers that could benefit from taking part in the show.

    If you think this would be of any interest to you or anyone in your network, please give me a call to discuss further. My phone number is 0203 301 8688

    Kindest regards,

    Hani

    ReplyDelete
  2. Much obliged for the energizing web journal posting about business plan assignment for students.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hello friends, my name's Andrea Maria, from Stockholm - Sweden. I read good comments about your good job, I'm very happy for you all as i have found same happiness in myself, just Few weeks ago i read a good testimony on similar blog website at my work office, a comment posted by a lady Jennifer from Madrid she said a Great man from Africana nation called Dr.Oduduwa was able to bring back her ex boyfriend after 12 months of break-up. i was motivated, I gave it a try to contact same Oduduwa via: (dr.oduduwaspellcaster@gmail. com) for urgent solution to restore back my marriage for about 2 years i have been separated. Just immediately i send email message to Dr.Oduduwa, I received immediate reply, he told me that he can help me, he said my case is too simple for him to handle because he have solve similar cases over the years. I gave it a try because i have nothing to loose from trying. he demanded for photo images and i bought candles and other spell materials required for a successful result. Two days ago which was Tuesday morning after love spell portion activated, i got a phone call from my ex husband man, he talked with me so nicely and apologize for breaking up with me, he explained to me that he was feeling very sorry, i forgive him and thank him for coming back. it was shocking and a big surprise to me, so quick i witness instant love spell result at work in my life up till today, we are much more in love than ever before we came to an agreement to start our family planning all over again. i never could imagine it will work so quickly until yesterday morning my husband man came back home to meet me and our two lovely kids we are all happy as one family.
    Dr.Oduduwa has great magic spell powers to resolve the following:...
    1) love spell portion to win games
    2) Restore back Lost Love Spells
    3) Divorce Spells
    4) Spouses' trust spouses
    5) binding spelling to living together forever
    6) Breakup Spells (terminate relationship)
    7) Magic roots and herbs for strong errection and long lasting sex
    8.) Magic spell promoted in your Job office
    9) Magic spell to have a baby. (women fruit of womb)
    Note: I was desperate to get back my ex love man, it work more faster only desperate ones seeking for urgent result to restore back true love and peace in marriage relationship to contact Dr.Oduduwa immediately. WhatsApp mobile: +79268011965

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thank you for sharing this informative post.MyAssignmenthelp.co.uk is giving economics assignment to students.we are already trusted by thousands of students who struggle to write their academic papers and also by those students who simply want economics assignment help to save their time and make life easy.

    ReplyDelete
  5. You can very easily get help from our experts of IdealAssignmenthelp together with your engineering assignments. you only need to take Engineering Assignment Help from our experts who will assist you with the engineering concepts and therefore the topics with the respective field and therefore the branch. you'll be able to solve these doubts and therefore the queries from our experts.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Global Interscope is the best swimming pools designing in Hyderabad where the you can get all the facilities to improve better.

    swimming pool contractors in hyderabad, Execution, Equipment Supplies, Services and Lifestyle Products.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Great post! The information you shared is great and very helpful for all. I am Tom Walker professional blogger, academic consultants at assignment help provider website ABCassignmenthelp.com

    ReplyDelete
  8. What a wonderful content shared here. I really benefited from your content. If you are experiencing trouble striking a balance between your busy academic life and handling your online classes, you can get help from a professional who will take online classes on your behalf. It doesn’t matter the kind of help you need, whether it is passing your exam, finishing your assignments or even the entire classwork, you can get help here at Online Class Help .

    ReplyDelete
  9. When I attempt to work on my laptop microphone, I am receiving the warning message such as laptop microphone not working error. This technical glitch has become a difficult problem for me. I am seeing the message that the microphone is not working on my laptop, I am experiencing a lot of difficulties to work on my microphone. There can be unexpected several causes of this technical problem. So, I am discussing this technical problem with you to get the permanent resolutions. Can you provide the simple ways to rectify this technical error.https://www.hpprintersupportpro.com/blog/hp-laptop-microphone-not-working/
    windows 10 mic not working
    microphone not working windows 10
    windows 10 microphone not working
    microphone not working
    windows 10 mic not working
    laptop microphone not working
    laptop mic not working
    hewlett packard laptop troubleshooting
    hp laptop microphone not working windows 10

    ReplyDelete
  10. Sometimes connection manager fails to show devices and display HP Connection Manager Fatal Error. If you are facing the same problem and unable solve it then contact experts to get immediate help. Certified techies are available round the clock to help customers.

    ReplyDelete
  11. The HP printer installationis one of the easiest things to do. The installation process is very easy as compared to other printing brands. You just need to visit the HP Printer site, select the model type of your HP printer. If the model is not given, enter your HP Printer Model Number in the search tab. After mentioning the same click on the OK Button and the list of all the drivers will appear in front of you. Download them one by one. Open the downloaded files and give the run command. Click on the Install now button and wait till the install gets complete. Reboot the system and your HP Printer Installation is completed. For any further help, contact to the HP Support team

    ReplyDelete
  12. QuickBooks is that the most powerful and efficient accounting software that helps businesses of all sizes for maintaining the records of daily financial transactions. While using QuickBooks, I’m experiencing QuickBooks won’t open error. This error could also be extremely frustrating and annoying. Thousands of QuickBooks users are experiencing many errors like QuickBooks isn’t opening, QuickBooks has stopped working or won’t open company file.

    ReplyDelete
  13. So using it is very important for users. While attempting to send roadrunner emails, you may experience Roadrunner email not working error. This technical bug is very hard to be solved, so taking quality assistance from experienced technicians is very important.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Such a wonderful information blog post on this topic CrazyForStudy provides assignment service at affordable cost in a wide range of subject areas for all grade levels, we are already trusted by thousands of students who struggle to write their academic papers and also by those students who simply want Report Writing Help to save their time and make life easy.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I agree with the facts you stated above. You have a beautiful flow with words. For students who are struggling to write their assignments on their own, I suggest they choose the Harvard Referencing Generator service of LiveWebTutors. It is a perfect and affordable platform that helps you to achieve top grades in your academic activities.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I am using roadrunner technical support for my business deal hence I depend on this emailing service. From a few days, I am experiencing roadrunner email not working problem.

    ReplyDelete
  17. ALT Text Writing is one of a service used to maintain manuals and textbooks for the visually impaired and folks with other learning disabilities. Our highly skilled online alt Text writers have the aptitude to understand ideas and designs.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I find it very difficult to understand your whole explanation, I'm thinking of discussing it with PhD Dissertation Writing Services experts to clear the points.

    ReplyDelete
  19. You might feel like asking, “How to write an essay” due to a lack of clear concept. Our assignment helpers are highly experienced and have a vast knowledge. Thus, they can easily prepare a highly informative and well-structured essay for you. With their assignment help, you can also clear out all your concepts.

    ReplyDelete
  20. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  21. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  22. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Get the best Business Law Assignment Help by experts at affordable prices. Get the best Business Law Assignment Help from UK by professional assignment writers of UK. On-Time Delivery. A+ Quality.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Well, Now you need not to worry about your pending assignment writing.Native assignment help is one of the best assignment service provider in UK. We are here to give you best assignment help UK based service. Browse our services of Economics Assignment Help Edinburgh, Manchester and Across UK.

    ReplyDelete
  25. My marriage was going so well when all of a sudden my husband started having an extra marital affair with his secretary and when I found out he no longer comes home. I started searching for help because I can't raise the kids alone and this was when I met almighty Dr Okolo who told me not to worry about it and that he was gonna restore back my marriage. That was how he did a spell casting and my husband came to me pleading for all his been doing behind my back.. Thank you  Dr Okolo . You're a man of your words. Have any problem.. COURT CASES SPELL, LOVE SPELL, MARRIAGE SPELL, DEATH SPELL LOTTERY SPELL  ETC..Dr Okolo will help you...email drokolosolutioncenter@gmail.com WhatsApp +2347031895935 

    ReplyDelete
  26. HP printers are known for their consistency and reliability. They are also highly affordable in comparison to other printers available in the market. <a href="https://www.assistanceforall.com/services/printer-support/hp-printer-support/</a>

    ReplyDelete
  27. Quickbboks is an accounting software that be used to accounting, payroll, some time user face the issue with this the company file not open and problem Quickbooks won't open. Many methods to resolve these issues.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Hlww everyone i worked in a it company and we are here to resolve your issues so if anyone is facing error quickbook error 15215 server not responding so here is a article by the professionals so that you can go through it and can resolve your problems regarding this issuequickbooks unexpected error 5

    ReplyDelete
  29. good to read it.
    sage 50 vs quickbooks both are online accounting software quikbooks are mainly used in small and mid sized companies while the sage was focud on big companies

    ReplyDelete
  30. Assignment Help online was started not as a result of we saw there was a large interest for these services, however, because we wished to supply one thing higher to the students

    ReplyDelete
  31. Hi admin, I am curious to know what new trending topic and assignment work come in your service. I want to see brief description with the internal inking of affordable assignment help USA service.

    ReplyDelete
  32. I have gone through many assignment writing services for reducing the academic pressure. But, I have your website best from the rest services. I am greatly influence with ready to move tools in terms of word counter, spell, check, grammar check. Before going in the final submission service, I use this tool to attain the sure approval rate.

    ReplyDelete
  33. No words about your thoughts + suggestions that you shared here. You completed a few fine tips there. I did a search on the topic and I found nearly all readers will go along with with your articles. The information here will surely be of some help to me. Helpful things you've always shared with us. Hope so just continue composing this kind of post. Thankyou guys. paraphrasing services - assignment help in australia - assignment help sydney - assignment help in melbourne

    ReplyDelete
  34. I visit your blog. It is really useful and easy to understand. Hope everyone gets benefit. Thanks for sharing your Knowledge and experience with us.
    wordpress
    ufa88kh.blogspot
    youtube
    online poker

    ReplyDelete

  35. Commemorative speech topics have various categories like students can write up love and siblings commemorative speech topics, elementary commemorative speech topics, commemorative speech topics social rights, and lastly the list of best commemorative speech topics for social education

    ReplyDelete
  36. This is a nice post in an interesting line of content.Thanks for sharing this article, great way of bring this topic to discussion.

    sfu canvas

    ReplyDelete
  37. We provide the best capsim simulations assignment help. We will guide you through all capsim business rounds..

    ReplyDelete
  38. Great Article it is really informative and innovative keep us posted with new updates.it was really valuable. thanks a lot.

    HND Assignment Help

    ReplyDelete

  39. Honestly its unique market approach, I appreciate your effort in making out something useful and knowledgeable out of your time. Good and intelligent work. Many thanks for sharing. visit ekounimed university cut off mark for electrical engineering

    ReplyDelete
  40. The word “FAMILY” plays a vital role in every human life because family comes as a top priority; we are well aware of that. Like a tree has its root, stem, branches, leaf, flowers, the same as the family tree has its structure like grandparents, parents, child, and it keeps continuing from generation to generation. “Family tree,” yeah, just two simple words, but these two words are highly important for everyone’s life.

    ReplyDelete
  41. Interesting read, I loved the content I bookmarked the website for regular read CMI Assignment Help is tailor made and pocket friendly to our client.

    ReplyDelete
  42. You had penned your thoughts beautifully. I’m looking for more content like this. Till then, you can create your birth chart by using the Free Kundli Calculator.

    Best time to plan child according to Kundli || Baby name as per horoscope || IVF Pregnancy and Astrology

    ReplyDelete
  43. So, if you desire to get compensated for jetblue flight delay compensation, it is precise to take a look at your contract or carriage to understand what JetBlue Airlines say about delays and what compensations to expect.

    ReplyDelete
  44. Hi, your blog is truly faultless and unique. Wonderful contents, this is the best article i read with more information than any other blog zone. I liked it. Thank you so much for sharing this article with us. visit more info custom coursework writing and cheapest essay writing service.

    ReplyDelete
  45. Its super cool great work that the revenue management have done to have written this nice piece. Thanks so much for sharing. Also visit akanu-ibiam fed-poly school fees for part time

    ReplyDelete
  46. It’s really a cool and useful piece of info. I’m satisfied that you shared this helpful info with us. Thank you so much for sharing. Also visit https://healthylifehuman.com/remove-makeup-at-home/

    ReplyDelete
  47. The Teach India NGO, Delhi office allows people in Delhi to volunteer and teaches children in underprivileged schools. Volunteers work with children one-on-one or in small groups to help them improve their academic performance.

    ReplyDelete
  48. Hotel Madhuvan is the Best Budget Hotel in Mathura Vrindavan. Our rooms are clean and spacious, and our prices are unbeatable. We are located in the heart of Mathura, close to all the major temples and attractions. Our staff is friendly and helpful, and we offer various services to make your stay comfortable and enjoyable.

    ReplyDelete
  49. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  50. Thank goodness

    Happy to have my boyfriend back after our breakup,

    Get Your Lover Back & Avoid breakup,

    Help That Really Work Fast,

    Contact him for Relationship/marital problem,

    R.buckler11 (@) g m a i l. com,

    ReplyDelete
  51. Amazing and well written post .
    We have a team with vast experience in academic writing. Our team has professionals with relevant industry experience, who are focused on helping students with Public Economics assignment help. We work on Affordability, Plagiarism free solution, Availability and Professionalism in delivering assignments to students .

    ReplyDelete
  52. This is due to the fact that the piece stands out among the other notable information that is located on the website. how to make homemade pastaa

    ReplyDelete
  53. Hello! I'm Jack, your trusted source for Accounting Assignment Help Online at Native Assignment Help. Our mission is to provide comprehensive support tailored to your academic needs. With years of experience and a dedicated team, we ensure top-quality assistance for your accounting assignments. Let us guide you through complex concepts and achieve your academic goals together. Reach out today and experience the difference with our Accounting Assignment Help Online services!

    ReplyDelete
  54. At Native Assignment Help, we curate compelling Forensic Science Dissertation Topics to ignite scholarly pursuits. Our meticulously crafted selection of Forensic Science Dissertation Topics caters to academic excellence, fostering innovative research avenues. Explore our platform for comprehensive guidance on Forensic Science Dissertation Topics, designed to elevate your academic journey. With our expertise, delve into the intricacies of Forensic Science Dissertation Topics and unravel groundbreaking insights.

    ReplyDelete